The Broadcast Battlefront
September 1st, 2009If there were a 12-step program for television, my daughter would be a prime candidate. Given the opportunity, she would watch the tube most of the day. There are very few things she’d rather do than watch a movie or TVOKids. Of course, this isn’t a new or unique problem. Rudolph Dreikurs, author of the classic parenting book Children: The Challenge devoted a whole chapter to “meeting the challenge of tv”. He discussed the perils of “passive” entertainment and the amount of poor quality programming, or “trash”, that’s on the air. Mealtimes, bedtimes, and family time have all been disrupted, he writes, leading to fighting and tension at home.
His book, by the way, was written in 1964. Apparently, not much has changed.
One of the things that has changed is that there is without question a better selection of quality kids’ programs on television today. While there certainly still is an awful lot of junk being broadcast today, it can be easier as a parent to relax about tv watching these days because of shows that emphasize reading and vocabulary, social skills, physical fitness, and cultural awareness. But most of us have to admit that our kids watch more television than they “should” or that it has sometimes taken on the role of electronic babysitter.
As parents, we might react to this situation by feeling as though we need to do something to manage the tv situation. But in reality, it is a family problem, and can be more effectively resolved by the family as a whole. This is a great discussion for a family meeting: how much television is appropriate, what shows are appropriate, how do we balance television with responsibilities such as homework, chores, and bedtimes. Instead of Mom or Dad being the heavy who lays down the law, Dreikurs suggests that when a problem or a conflict arises, the question the parent asks is, “What is to be done now?”, putting the onus back on the child to participate in finding a solution.
He also makes some good points about fighting with our kids over what they can and can’t watch. As soon as we ban a particular program, that’s all our kids can think about. They may not be able to watch it when we’re home, but there are increasingly more and more avenues to watch programs, outside of the family room television. This is a great opportunity to help your children develop critical thinking skills. Watch some of these questionable shows with your kids, then have a discussion afterward: What did you think of that? Did you agree with the choices that were made? How do you think the others felt? What else do you think they could have done? This is not an opportunity to “correct” the thinking of our kids, but to ask them some open-ended questions and let them consider some new ways of looking at the situation. If you think the show is so extremely inappropriate that you can’t even bear the thought of sitting together and allowing your kids to watch even one episode, discuss the show instead. Remember, anything that is banned becomes just that much more appealing and there’s a good chance they’ll find a way to watch it anyway, so this is a good opportunity to demystify the show and remove the “charge” from the situation. If television isn’t the source of a power struggle, it often becomes less and less of a big deal, and less and less interesting.
Because the reality is that television is only as important as we make it. Remember my daughter the junkie? There’s only one thing she has a greater addiction to than the tube: spending time with her family. She will cheerfully run off and leave the tv forgotten for a chance to go with us to the park, to the store, to the kitchen to do some baking. As always, the most potent force in a child’s life is not the lure of hours of channel surfing, but the undivided attention of her family.

